Is Your Soil Test Telling You the Whole Story? Rethinking Soil Fertility with Grant Wells

For decades, farmers have relied on soil testing to make decisions about fertilizer applications, nutrient management, and crop production. But what if those tests aren’t telling the whole story?

As input costs continue to pressure farm profitability, understanding what nutrients are actually available to crops—not simply what nutrients exist in the soil—could change how farmers approach fertility management.

On a recent episode of The Whole Farm Podcast, CHONEX sits down with Iowa farmer and agricultural entrepreneur Grant Wells to explore the limitations he sees in traditional soil testing, the science behind plant-available nutrients, and how better data could help farmers make more informed financial decisions.

The Disconnect Between Soil Tests and Crop Performance

Grant Wells didn’t set out to reinvent soil testing.

Growing up on his family’s Iowa farm, which his grandfather started in 1940, Grant originally envisioned taking over the operation. After losing his father in a farming accident while attending college, he ultimately pursued a path that combined farming with his growing interest in agricultural sales.

He built an independent agricultural retail business with a straightforward commitment: earn farmers’ trust by providing honest recommendations backed by research.

Rather than immediately recommending new products, Grant established a three-year evaluation process on his own research farm.

But the results raised questions.

Certain micronutrient and foliar applications produced noticeable yield responses in some fields, while the same treatments produced little or no response elsewhere.

When Grant began comparing soil tests with plant tissue samples, he noticed something unexpected: soil nutrient measurements weren’t consistently correlating with what was getting into the plant.

That observation sparked years of investigation and eventually contributed to the creation of BW Fusion in 2018.

It also led Grant to a fundamental question: Are farmers measuring the right things when making fertility decisions?

Traditional Soil Testing vs. Plant-Available Nutrients

Traditional soil testing has long been a cornerstone of nutrient management.

Common testing methods, including Bray, Mehlich, and Olsen phosphorus tests, use chemical extractants to estimate nutrient availability. These measurements help agronomists evaluate soil fertility and develop recommendations.

However, Grant argues that conventional testing doesn’t always provide the information farmers need to understand nutrient availability throughout the growing season.

A soil may contain substantial reserves of phosphorus or potassium, but that doesn’t necessarily mean all those nutrients are immediately accessible to the crop.

Grant believes this distinction is especially important when farmers are investing significant amounts of money in fertilizer.

If a farmer’s goal is to produce a profitable crop, understanding the relationship between soil nutrients, plant uptake, and yield potential becomes critical.

Traditional soil tests remain useful tools, but Grant challenges the industry to look beyond a single set of nutrient values when making decisions.

Why the Haney Soil Test Offers a Different Perspective

One approach Grant discusses is the Haney soil test, which incorporates measurements intended to provide additional insight into nutrient availability and soil biological processes.

The Haney method uses H3A extraction to assess nutrients such as phosphorus and potassium. It also measures water-extractable organic carbon, an indicator associated with the carbon resources available to soil microorganisms.

This matters because soil biology plays an important role in nutrient cycling.

Microbial activity helps transform nutrients into forms plants can use, meaning the biological condition of the soil can influence how effectively crops access fertility.

Grant emphasizes that understanding this relationship requires looking at more than a single nutrient number.

But even with more detailed testing, another challenge remains: where and how soil samples are collected.

Why Soil Variability Matters

Not every acre of a field behaves the same way.

Hilltops, side slopes, and low-lying areas can have different soil characteristics, water dynamics, and nutrient cycling conditions.

Traditional grid sampling divides fields into regularly spaced sections. While this approach can provide valuable information, Grant points out that a grid doesn’t necessarily follow the natural differences within a field.

A single composite sample could include soil from multiple landscape positions.

That can make it harder to understand how fertility varies across those areas.

In the podcast, Grant describes how Top Soil’s Baseline soil testing system, developed by Next Ag Lab, combines landscape-based soil zones with Haney testing and plant tissue data.

According to Grant, the system uses topography and soil characteristics to create more meaningful sampling zones, with the goal of improving predictions of nutrient availability as crops develop.

Rather than relying solely on a snapshot of soil conditions, the approach aims to anticipate what nutrients will be available when crops need them.

Connecting Soil Fertility to Farm Profitability

Perhaps the most compelling part of Grant’s approach isn’t just the soil science.

It’s what that information could mean for a farmer’s bottom line.

Fertilizer is a major expense, and every growing season involves balancing potential yield against financial risk.

Should a farmer invest in additional fertility to pursue higher yields? Or could reducing unnecessary inputs provide a better financial outcome?

Grant believes those decisions should be guided by measurable information rather than assumptions.

Through Top Soil’s Baseline system, he describes an approach designed to estimate the fertility investments needed to pursue different yield goals.

For example, a farmer evaluating a 180-bushel corn yield goal versus a 250-bushel goal could compare estimated fertility requirements and costs against the potential return.

That doesn’t eliminate weather risk, market volatility, or uncertainty. But it could provide another tool for evaluating whether additional fertilizer spending makes financial sense.

For farmers operating on tight margins, those decisions can be significant.

The goal isn’t necessarily to maximize yield at any cost.

It’s to find the right balance between fertility investment, production potential, and financial risk.

A Mission Rooted in Faith and Service

While soil testing is a central focus of the episode, Grant’s personal story provides important context for his work.

After building multiple agricultural businesses, Grant describes a significant transformation in his Christian faith in 2023.

That experience led him to reconsider the purpose behind his work and the legacy he wanted to build.

Rather than viewing business growth as the ultimate measure of success, he began focusing more intentionally on how his work could serve others.

That perspective helped shape his vision for Top Soil: a network of local agents who could bring more advanced soil testing and fertility management tools directly to family farms.

Grant sees the model as an opportunity to support local relationships, provide practical guidance, and help farming operations navigate increasingly difficult financial decisions.

The Future of Soil Testing: Better Data, Better Decisions

Agriculture continues to evolve, and so do the tools available to help farmers understand their soil.

For Grant Wells, the future of soil testing isn’t simply about generating more data.

It’s about making that data useful.

Understanding plant-available nutrients, recognizing differences within a field, and connecting fertility recommendations to financial outcomes could help farmers make more informed decisions about their largest investments.

The conversation also raises a broader question for agriculture:

Are we managing fertility based on what we’ve always measured, or are we measuring what farmers actually need to know?

That’s a question worth asking as producers look for ways to improve nutrient efficiency, protect profitability, and build more resilient farming operations.

Hear the Full Conversation on The Whole Farm Podcast

In Part 1 of this two-part episode, Grant Wells joins CHONEX to discuss his journey in agriculture, the limitations he sees in conventional soil testing, and his vision for connecting soil fertility to farm financial performance.

Part 2 will continue the conversation with a deeper look at nutrient management challenges across different production systems.

Listen to Part 1 of The Whole Farm Podcast, and subscribe so you don’t miss the next conversation.